Difference between revisions of "User:Vincecate/FloatingVilla"

From Seasteading
Jump to: navigation, search
(Location)
(Future Versions)
 
(115 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Rental houses in [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anguilla Anguilla] are called villas.  This proposal is to make money renting out an early seastead prototype off the coast of Anguilla.  This could also be called a "seastead resort".
+
[[Image:Waterwalker3.jpg]]
 +
 
 +
This type of [[seastead]] plan is an example of the [[Protected Waters]] strategy that should lead to a [[Single Family Seastead]] and [[User:Vincecate/SeasteadingViews|evolve into full seastead communities]].  We plan to start out someplace where the waves are not too big.
 +
 
 +
Rental houses in [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anguilla Anguilla] are called villas.  This proposal is to make money renting out early smaller seasteads off the coast of Anguilla.  After we get a few seasteads operational, it could be called a "seastead resort". It is a bit like [http://www.tahiti.hotel-pictures.com/tuamotu/manihi/Overwater.html overwater bungalows in Tahiti] but floating instead of on columns.  I made a
 +
video on this idea for Seasteading 2009 conference.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<youtube v="p4icNUDqNIg" />
 +
 
 +
 
  
 
==Taxes==
 
==Taxes==
  
In Anguilla there is no income tax or sales tax.  However, there is a "hotel tax" or "visitor tax", officially called the "transient persons act".  The government gets a 10% cut on the price of any room rented by the day or week.   
+
In Anguilla there is no income tax or sales tax.  However, there is a "hotel tax" or "visitor tax", officially covered in the "transient persons act".  Basically there is a 10% tax on any room rented by the day or week.  There is also a 10% service charge for the staff, though this seems to be a guideline or regulation and not exactly law.
  
==Financial estimate==
+
==Stabilizers==
  
Anguilla villas are mostly full from Christmas to US Tax day (Apr 15). So there is about 4 months that people are fleeing the cold weather up in the US and coming to Anguilla. If a house got $500/night (plus the tax that goes to the government) for 4 months this would be about $60,000 for the ventureFor this back of the envelope type estimate lets assume that you make enough during the rest of the year that the $60,000 is profit. A loan at 10% for $600,000 could sort of be paid with this profitSo if you could build a seastead for less than this, or charge more per night than this, you could be profitable.
+
There is a [http://www.boatstabilizers.net/ boat stabilizer for while at anchor]If we put one of these under each corner it could dissipate enough energy that bobbing would not be a problem even for a spar/cylinder shaped float (instead of a sphere)It might be good to get an even larger stabilizer made than the standard sizes.
  
I think we could start with something under $60,000 that could be rented for $100/day to some students or young adventurous types.  I have some [[User:Vincecate/Tension_circle_house#Future_Models|ideas on how to build something small]].
+
== Floats ==
 +
 
 +
A nice thing about round floats is that up/down motion makes a wave which gets rid of that energy.  There is no memory of the last wave that can get things bobbing up and down out of phase with the waves.
 +
 
 +
It should be possible to make floats that are more spar shaped (small waterline area) but still have this feature of getting rid of up/down energy by making a wave.  It is sort of a compromise between a ball and a long skinny pole.  Just have a float that is pointy at the top and bottom but wider in the middle.  Then as it goes up and down it will make a wave, so it will not bob out of phase.  This is safer than a pure spar shape if the stabilizers fail.  It also sort of helps the stabilizer.
 +
 
 +
==Non-stretch Rope==
 +
 
 +
The [http://dynexdux.com/ Dynex Dux] rope is strong and has minimal stretch.  This would work well for the ropes in the structure.
 +
 
 +
==Financial Estimates==
 +
 
 +
This is probably around $100,000 to $200,000 US and should rent for about $1,000 to $2000 per week.  If we rent over 10 weeks per year it should be a reasonable investment.  A sort of break-even at 20% occupancy leaves room for good profits at higher occupancy levels.
 +
 
 +
I plan to get an engineer to spec out the parts with for aluminum and also steelThen I will get prices for those parts and an estimate for the welding.  So should get a better estimate of the cost.  Not sure yet if aluminum or steel is the way to go.
  
 
==Licenses and regulations==
 
==Licenses and regulations==
Line 15: Line 39:
 
Would need a "business license", but this is not usually hard to get, particularly for a local.
 
Would need a "business license", but this is not usually hard to get, particularly for a local.
  
A foreigner working on this venture would need a "work permit".
+
A foreigner working in Anguilla would need a "work permit". The support work is best done by locals.  By this I mean maid service, maintenance, water taxi, etc.  If people came down to assemble a seastead and were not getting paid (strictly volunteer) there should not be any problem. 
  
Seasteads would need a "boat license".  I am checking with the guy that does the boat inspections to see if this would be a problem.
+
If I build something and play with it, people in Anguilla probably won't care.  However, a seastead would need a "boat license" if it has a motor and tourists were going to go on itCould start without a motor and maybe not rent to the public.  A boat license takes certification by some place outside Anguilla.  At
 +
[http://www.nmma.org/certification/ NMMA], the first place I checked, this certification would cost about  [http://www.nmma.org/lib/docs/nmma/cert/2009_Boat_and_Yacht_Certification_Agreement.pdf $2,500 plus travel costs].  So this is probably affordable, though it may be more than this as this design will be very different than what they are used to certifying.  The seastead would probably be classified as a "house boat".  We might need to test it for a year or something for people to get comfortable with the design.  It may not be reasonable to expect to have paying customers on what is really an experimental prototype.  Or maybe engineering, CAD design, and simulation is advanced enough these days that this is reasonable.
  
==Location==
+
I sent the NMMA people a link to my tension circle page to check if they could certify such a thing as a boat.  Their answer was if it had propulsion and/or the US Coast Guard would issue me an MIC (Manufacturers Identification
 +
Code) designated for boat builders then they could.  I could [http://www.ncwaterways.com/BusinessAssistance/Regulatory/Builders/MIC%20info.htm get an MIC code] or have someone with one build the vessel.  We should understand how to use
 +
[http://technology.newscientist.com/article/dn14663 large low RPM propellers] for efficient movement at slow speeds, so putting an engine on is something we need to do sometime anyway.  Even with kites for open ocean, I think we need engines for harbors.
  
Starting out with just one or two seasteads they could be located close to landBut I think it would be best to be a few miles out. A [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.257882,-63.142033&spn=0.0745,0.11055&z=13 nice spot north of Anguilla] is on the downwind side of the island and inside a reef while [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.238482,-63.090534&spn=0.074508,0.11055&z=13 a few miles offshore].  Far enough out and the seasteads could be out of sight, and "out of sight is out of mind".  If you are paying 10% to the government and not bothering anybody I don't think there would be any trouble.
+
If it does not have motors/engines/sales/kites but is just a floating house it is not clear what it needs.
 +
 
 +
==How to get Anguilla Planning Permission==
 +
 
 +
It seems that I should get Anguilla planning permission if it is going to be a villa.  I played my Seasteading 09 talk and had a short talk with a couple people in planning.  They thought the idea was interesting and told me I need to write up a proposal and then it goes before the board.  I expect to do this.
 +
 
 +
There is a villa tax.  It might be treated like a boat too, it is not clear.  Other questions,  like  do I pay duty if I bring it to location but never land it on shore?  If the boat is registered someplace else, are there fees for parking 2 miles offshore?
 +
 
 +
==First Location==
 +
 
 +
[[Image:Locationview.jpg]]
 +
 
 +
The location I like is a [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.259675,-63.10667&spn=0.074499,0.11055&z=13 nice spot north of Anguilla].  It is on the downwind side of the island and inside a reef while [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.238482,-63.090534&spn=0.074508,0.11055&z=13 a few miles offshore].  So it is sort of out in the ocean but sort of protected so the waves are not too bad.  Here is a chart showing that the dark blue area in the first link just [http://cate.com/anguilla/chart.gif inside the reef is about 20 meters deep].  It is far enough that people won't notice it much.  It is almost an "out of sight is out of mind" situation.  If you are paying 10% to the government and not bothering anybody I don't think there would be any trouble.  It is also not far from [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.252355,-63.028446&spn=0.002328,0.003455&z=18 my dome] and within line-of-sight from a building I have on the top of our hill.  So about 3 miles offshore, [http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&t=h&ll=18.220689,-63.067934&spn=0.002329,0.003455&z=18 4 miles from a good harbor], and around 5 miles from my property (picture above is from my property).  Another nice thing about this location is there is a water taxi based in the nearby harbor.  The view is wonderful, the wind is nice, the reef amazing, the water clear, and not many people around.  I think it is a location people would love to spend time at.
  
 
==Tourist activity==
 
==Tourist activity==
  
Going ashore from 10 miles out could take 20 minutes or more one way.  To begin with they may only be 2-5 miles out, but still it would be nice if there was entertainment near the seastead. Be good if people could have enough fun that they might stay in the area for the whole week.  Some possibilities are:
+
Going the 4 miles to the harbor could take 10 to 20 minutes one way.  It would be nice if there was entertainment near the seastead. Be good if people could have enough fun things to do that they could stay by the villa most of the week.  Some possibilities are:
  
 +
* [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nq8Fn55axd4&NR=1 Amphibious ATV] or some [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HEQJ7xDwzHo Amphibious Jeep] for playing on water and land
 
* scuba diving
 
* scuba diving
 
* snorkeling
 
* snorkeling
Line 32: Line 72:
 
* kayaks
 
* kayaks
 
* kite surfing
 
* kite surfing
* jet-skis
+
* practice [http://online.offshore.com.ai/balseros/ kite powered life raft evacuation to downwind island]
* fishing
+
* power boats (jet-skis not allowed in Anguilla)
* operating an [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ROV ROV]
+
* glass bottom boat (guy here in Anguilla could pick them up at seastead)
 +
* fishing from seastead or boat
 +
* operating an [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ROV ROV] - maybe catching lobster by remote control
 
* restaurant/bar/food delivery   
 
* restaurant/bar/food delivery   
 
* lobster traps
 
* lobster traps
 +
* internet (wireless providers and line-of-site to my place)
 +
* phone (cell phone is easy, as is Internet phone)
 +
 +
Anguilla has a hotel named "Cuisinart" that has a hydroponic greenhouse.  Tourists find the tour of the greenhouse very interesting.  A similar thing could be done with the seasteads.  Perhaps a combination of a micro-version of the [http://www.edenproject.com/ Eden project] and the [http://www.duravermeerbusinessdevelopment.nl/uk/project_info.asp?id=578 floating greenhouses] developed by Dutch firm Dura Vermeer?  Fish farming could be fun.  Anything we were experimenting with, testing, developing could be of interest to someone who picked this vacation spot.
 +
 +
==Baby steps==
 +
 +
This a relatively easy first step that should be profitable.  Being close to land avoids the problems of communication and transportation.  At this distance the regular cell towers work and there is wireless Internet.  A good harbor being 4 miles away makes getting people and cargo there easy.  The island has an airport so people can come from all over. 
 +
 +
This lets us test out prototypes and make money from them.  If we can make money off our R&D efforts, then the capital investment needed to get to the final goal is much smaller.
 +
 +
==Future Versions==
 +
 +
Could make versions with some [[Thrusters]] that use [[PropellerEfficiency|Big Efficient Propellers]] so it could move around slowly.  Could make larger versions.  Could test in deep ocean waves.  I currently plan to use mixers as thrusters.  These would lower down into the water from the legs a bit above the waterline. 
 +
 +
Over time we can put seasteads outside the reef and further and further out.  If there is a storm coming we could bring the seasteads back inside the reef (maybe leave an empty one out in the storm for testing).  Eventually we would have a group of seasteads that we trusted enough to  go out into the open ocean. 
 +
 +
If we want to take tourists on [[User:Vincecate/Migration|Migration]] routes we will need licensed boats to go to the islands.  So going through the license procedure is something we will need to do anyway.
 +
 +
==Conclusion==
 +
 +
This is an incremental plan.  It has a very low initial cost.  It makes money along the way.  It [[User:Vincecate/SeasteadingViews|eventually gets to our goal]] of seasteads out in the open ocean.
 +
 +
 +
== Next steps ==
 +
 +
Making a model that fixed problems found in first model and tested float idea.  Might even try to model stabilizers.
 +
 +
Getting government license.
 +
 +
== Possible Main Parts - leading candidates ==
 +
 +
A
 +
[http://www.onlinemetals.com/merchant.cfm?pid=13215&step=4&showunits=inches&id=980&top_cat=60 12-inch by 7-inch aluminum I-beam 39 feet long is under $4000] and 30 feet is under $3000.  So if we get 3 I-beams of 39 feet and 3 of 30 feet the total is around $20,000.  At 14.3 lbs per foot this 39*3+30*3=207 feet comes to 2960 lbs.  I would rather have a box-beam than an I-beam.
 +
 +
This place sells [http://www.asianavaids.com/steel-mooring-buoys.html cylindrical steel buoys] from 2.9 M long and 1.6 diameter up to 4.4 meters long and 2.5 meters in diameter.  I think what we need is in this range.
 +
 +
== Possible Main Parts - lower chance ==
  
Anguilla has a hotel named "Cuisinart" that has a hydroponic greenhouse.  Tourists find the tour of the greenhouse very interesting.  A similar thing could be done with the seasteads.  Perhaps a combination of a micro-version of the [http://www.edenproject.com/ Eden project] and the [http://www.duravermeerbusinessdevelopment.nl/uk/project_info.asp?id=578 floating greenhouses] developed by Dutch firm Dura Vermeer? Anything we were experimenting with, testing, developing could be of interest to someone who picked this vacation spot.
+
A [http://www.trelleborg.com/en/Trelleborg-Marine-Systems/Products/Fender-Systems/Foam-Buoys/SeaFloat/ huge buoy called SeaFloat]The one in the picture is too big.
  
==Internet==
+
These [http://www.blueoceantackle.com/spherical_steel_buoys.htm 58-inch spherical steel buoys have 3000 lbs buoyancy] so 3 would give 9000 lbs.  We only use half the potential buoyancy on average, so 4500 lbs usable for us.  We probably need larger unless the I-beams above are too large.  This same place says cylindrical buoys can be made to order.
  
This close to land Internet is easy.
+
The [http://www.polyformus.com/doc/product_a7.htm Polyform A-7].

Latest revision as of 00:08, 31 March 2010

Waterwalker3.jpg

This type of seastead plan is an example of the Protected Waters strategy that should lead to a Single Family Seastead and evolve into full seastead communities. We plan to start out someplace where the waves are not too big.

Rental houses in Anguilla are called villas. This proposal is to make money renting out early smaller seasteads off the coast of Anguilla. After we get a few seasteads operational, it could be called a "seastead resort". It is a bit like overwater bungalows in Tahiti but floating instead of on columns. I made a video on this idea for Seasteading 2009 conference.


<youtube v="p4icNUDqNIg" />


Taxes

In Anguilla there is no income tax or sales tax. However, there is a "hotel tax" or "visitor tax", officially covered in the "transient persons act". Basically there is a 10% tax on any room rented by the day or week. There is also a 10% service charge for the staff, though this seems to be a guideline or regulation and not exactly law.

Stabilizers

There is a boat stabilizer for while at anchor. If we put one of these under each corner it could dissipate enough energy that bobbing would not be a problem even for a spar/cylinder shaped float (instead of a sphere). It might be good to get an even larger stabilizer made than the standard sizes.

Floats

A nice thing about round floats is that up/down motion makes a wave which gets rid of that energy. There is no memory of the last wave that can get things bobbing up and down out of phase with the waves.

It should be possible to make floats that are more spar shaped (small waterline area) but still have this feature of getting rid of up/down energy by making a wave. It is sort of a compromise between a ball and a long skinny pole. Just have a float that is pointy at the top and bottom but wider in the middle. Then as it goes up and down it will make a wave, so it will not bob out of phase. This is safer than a pure spar shape if the stabilizers fail. It also sort of helps the stabilizer.

Non-stretch Rope

The Dynex Dux rope is strong and has minimal stretch. This would work well for the ropes in the structure.

Financial Estimates

This is probably around $100,000 to $200,000 US and should rent for about $1,000 to $2000 per week. If we rent over 10 weeks per year it should be a reasonable investment. A sort of break-even at 20% occupancy leaves room for good profits at higher occupancy levels.

I plan to get an engineer to spec out the parts with for aluminum and also steel. Then I will get prices for those parts and an estimate for the welding. So should get a better estimate of the cost. Not sure yet if aluminum or steel is the way to go.

Licenses and regulations

Would need a "business license", but this is not usually hard to get, particularly for a local.

A foreigner working in Anguilla would need a "work permit". The support work is best done by locals. By this I mean maid service, maintenance, water taxi, etc. If people came down to assemble a seastead and were not getting paid (strictly volunteer) there should not be any problem.

If I build something and play with it, people in Anguilla probably won't care. However, a seastead would need a "boat license" if it has a motor and tourists were going to go on it. Could start without a motor and maybe not rent to the public. A boat license takes certification by some place outside Anguilla. At NMMA, the first place I checked, this certification would cost about $2,500 plus travel costs. So this is probably affordable, though it may be more than this as this design will be very different than what they are used to certifying. The seastead would probably be classified as a "house boat". We might need to test it for a year or something for people to get comfortable with the design. It may not be reasonable to expect to have paying customers on what is really an experimental prototype. Or maybe engineering, CAD design, and simulation is advanced enough these days that this is reasonable.

I sent the NMMA people a link to my tension circle page to check if they could certify such a thing as a boat. Their answer was if it had propulsion and/or the US Coast Guard would issue me an MIC (Manufacturers Identification Code) designated for boat builders then they could. I could get an MIC code or have someone with one build the vessel. We should understand how to use large low RPM propellers for efficient movement at slow speeds, so putting an engine on is something we need to do sometime anyway. Even with kites for open ocean, I think we need engines for harbors.

If it does not have motors/engines/sales/kites but is just a floating house it is not clear what it needs.

How to get Anguilla Planning Permission

It seems that I should get Anguilla planning permission if it is going to be a villa. I played my Seasteading 09 talk and had a short talk with a couple people in planning. They thought the idea was interesting and told me I need to write up a proposal and then it goes before the board. I expect to do this.

There is a villa tax. It might be treated like a boat too, it is not clear. Other questions, like do I pay duty if I bring it to location but never land it on shore? If the boat is registered someplace else, are there fees for parking 2 miles offshore?

First Location

Locationview.jpg

The location I like is a nice spot north of Anguilla. It is on the downwind side of the island and inside a reef while a few miles offshore. So it is sort of out in the ocean but sort of protected so the waves are not too bad. Here is a chart showing that the dark blue area in the first link just inside the reef is about 20 meters deep. It is far enough that people won't notice it much. It is almost an "out of sight is out of mind" situation. If you are paying 10% to the government and not bothering anybody I don't think there would be any trouble. It is also not far from my dome and within line-of-sight from a building I have on the top of our hill. So about 3 miles offshore, 4 miles from a good harbor, and around 5 miles from my property (picture above is from my property). Another nice thing about this location is there is a water taxi based in the nearby harbor. The view is wonderful, the wind is nice, the reef amazing, the water clear, and not many people around. I think it is a location people would love to spend time at.

Tourist activity

Going the 4 miles to the harbor could take 10 to 20 minutes one way. It would be nice if there was entertainment near the seastead. Be good if people could have enough fun things to do that they could stay by the villa most of the week. Some possibilities are:

  • Amphibious ATV or some Amphibious Jeep for playing on water and land
  • scuba diving
  • snorkeling
  • sailing
  • kayaks
  • kite surfing
  • practice kite powered life raft evacuation to downwind island
  • power boats (jet-skis not allowed in Anguilla)
  • glass bottom boat (guy here in Anguilla could pick them up at seastead)
  • fishing from seastead or boat
  • operating an ROV - maybe catching lobster by remote control
  • restaurant/bar/food delivery
  • lobster traps
  • internet (wireless providers and line-of-site to my place)
  • phone (cell phone is easy, as is Internet phone)

Anguilla has a hotel named "Cuisinart" that has a hydroponic greenhouse. Tourists find the tour of the greenhouse very interesting. A similar thing could be done with the seasteads. Perhaps a combination of a micro-version of the Eden project and the floating greenhouses developed by Dutch firm Dura Vermeer? Fish farming could be fun. Anything we were experimenting with, testing, developing could be of interest to someone who picked this vacation spot.

Baby steps

This a relatively easy first step that should be profitable. Being close to land avoids the problems of communication and transportation. At this distance the regular cell towers work and there is wireless Internet. A good harbor being 4 miles away makes getting people and cargo there easy. The island has an airport so people can come from all over.

This lets us test out prototypes and make money from them. If we can make money off our R&D efforts, then the capital investment needed to get to the final goal is much smaller.

Future Versions

Could make versions with some Thrusters that use Big Efficient Propellers so it could move around slowly. Could make larger versions. Could test in deep ocean waves. I currently plan to use mixers as thrusters. These would lower down into the water from the legs a bit above the waterline.

Over time we can put seasteads outside the reef and further and further out. If there is a storm coming we could bring the seasteads back inside the reef (maybe leave an empty one out in the storm for testing). Eventually we would have a group of seasteads that we trusted enough to go out into the open ocean.

If we want to take tourists on Migration routes we will need licensed boats to go to the islands. So going through the license procedure is something we will need to do anyway.

Conclusion

This is an incremental plan. It has a very low initial cost. It makes money along the way. It eventually gets to our goal of seasteads out in the open ocean.


Next steps

Making a model that fixed problems found in first model and tested float idea. Might even try to model stabilizers.

Getting government license.

Possible Main Parts - leading candidates

A 12-inch by 7-inch aluminum I-beam 39 feet long is under $4000 and 30 feet is under $3000. So if we get 3 I-beams of 39 feet and 3 of 30 feet the total is around $20,000. At 14.3 lbs per foot this 39*3+30*3=207 feet comes to 2960 lbs. I would rather have a box-beam than an I-beam.

This place sells cylindrical steel buoys from 2.9 M long and 1.6 diameter up to 4.4 meters long and 2.5 meters in diameter. I think what we need is in this range.

Possible Main Parts - lower chance

A huge buoy called SeaFloat. The one in the picture is too big.

These 58-inch spherical steel buoys have 3000 lbs buoyancy so 3 would give 9000 lbs. We only use half the potential buoyancy on average, so 4500 lbs usable for us. We probably need larger unless the I-beams above are too large. This same place says cylindrical buoys can be made to order.

The Polyform A-7.